Missing, presumed dead: A sensational murder case in Jamaica highlights the plight of many vulnerable Caribbean women

A popular Jamaican social media influencer, Donna-Lee Donaldson, who was reported missing on July 13, two days after she accompanied her boyfriend, Police Constable Noel Maitland, to his apartment in New Kingston, still has not been found โ€“ but by August 2, Maitland had been charged with her murder. Investigating officers at theย Jamaica Constabulary Forceย (JCF) surmise that Donaldson was killed between 4:00 and 8:00 p.m. on July 12.

Maitlandย was first arrestedย on July 27, following a case review by the Office of Public Prosecutions. The decision to charge him for the suspected murder was based on phone records and forensics. This high-profile case is just one of manyย tragic stories of femicideย across the Caribbean region.

In a thread, journalist Abka Fitz-Henley provided details of the alleged crime. The police theorised that Maitland may have received assistance in committing the crime, though no additional arrests have been made to date:


The reporter noted also that Maitland may โ€œface additional charges in connection with what the Police believe to be efforts to hide his involvement in the crime and frustrate the Police investigation.โ€

The charges followed days of growing anxiety and intense social media speculation over Donaldsonโ€™s disappearance. Supporters have kept up a relentless flood of online posts, including on several Instagram accounts created in support of Donaldson, as well as Facebook posts and Tik Tok and YouTube videos. Many of these posts include unsubstantiated rumours and wild theories about how Donaldson met her demise, who else may have been involved, why the investigation seemed to be going slowly, and whether or not there was a โ€œcover-upโ€ by the police. One account shared photographs of other Jamaican women reported missing.

Police Commissioner Antony Anderson reacted strongly,ย accusing Jamaicansย of posting โ€œfake news,โ€ creating confusion and adding to the challenges the police have faced in their investigations. He distinguished social media rumours from inaccurate media reports:

I am not referring to news with inaccuracies, I am referring to fabricated and misleading stories in relation to an investigation. Every time these fabrications are published they not only divert the attention of the police, but they further traumatise the grieving family and loved ones.

One Jamaican commented:


The search for Donaldson’s bodyย continuesย against the backdrop of continuous public protests by her supporters, followers and friends, who have demonstrated loudly with placards outside the apartment block where Donaldson was last seen, and at several public events throughout Jamaica’s just-concludedย Independence celebrations.

On the day when the accused was due to appear in court (although there was some confusion over the date) Donaldson’s fans also staged a protest:


The delay in Maitlandโ€™s first court appearance was reportedlyย due to a case fileย not having been submitted:


The court appearance was finally arranged forย August 12:


Meanwhile, a policewoman who allegedly has a relationship with Maitlandย was interviewedย as a witness for several hours by the Independent Commission of Investigations (INDECOM), which investigates abuses and misconduct by members of the security forces. One radio station made it clear that the policewoman is not under suspicion of involvement with the crime:


Both Donaldson and Maitland, who is also a record producer and founder of a label called One Time, knew and worked with a number of people in the entertainment world. Rumours spread that before he was charged, Maitland was visited at the police lock-up by popular dancehall deejayย Popcaanย โ€“ an allegation the deejayย has strongly deniedย in an angry tweet.

Another well-known dancehall figureย shared his thoughtsย after working with Donaldson:


Donaldson’s case has proven to be a sensational one, widely covered in local media and still the subject of much social media speculation. As police investigations continue, however, the remains of another woman who had been missing for several months were found:


Femicide is not only a Jamaican problem; it follows a persistent pattern of women missing and murdered across the region โ€“ and the steady flow of violence against women continues, as UN Women Caribbeanย observed:

The most common form of violence experienced by women globally is physical violence inflicted by an intimate partner. On average, at least one in three women is beaten, coerced into sex or otherwise abused by an intimate partner in the course of her lifetime. Within the Caribbean, violence against women is pervasive.

There are examples of Caribbean womenย being killed by a partnerย or former partner in local media reports almost daily. A 2016-2019ย surveyย of intimate partner violence conducted by UN Women showed thatย in Grenada, 29 percent of women said they had experienced physical and/or sexual violence. In Suriname, the percentage wasย even higher. In Jamaica and Trinidad and Tobago, the percentage of women suffering physical and/or sexual violence at the hands of their partners were 28 percent and 30 percent, respectively.

One St. Lucian succinctly described the vulnerability of Caribbean women:


The overwhelming question remains, โ€œWhen will it end?โ€